Make sure you confirmed the Are you sure? prompt; the page reloads afterwards. If the count does not drop, look for the red error box at the top of the dashboard — it lists each subscription that could not be filled and why (no meals left after allergens/dislikes/preferences, missing checkout record, payment error). Fix the cause on the subscription or the menu and click Auto Select Meals again; already-filled subscriptions are skipped, so re-running is safe. Also note the card only appears on the main dashboard while the day is closed and not finished — it is hidden (replaced by a muted "waiting" or "Day Closed" message) while the day is still open, once every member is assigned, or once the day is finished.